Isaac Poobalan – real Christianity and real Islam

I do not really understand the pleasures of prejudice. I was brought up to detest it, and the enduring legacy that my difficult, demanding, unsatisfied father gave me was a conviction that other people are interesting and  approachable. A rock solid belief that it is going to be rewarding for both me and them if we meet as equals. I never realised just what a wonderful lesson and legacy this was until I got out into a world where people do not merely judge others, but pre-judge them based on a position of total ignorance about what they believe and what they stand for.


I am not alone in my conviction that we need to encounter others as real people, because the really-rather-wonderful Isaac Poobalan of  St John’s Episcopal Church in Aberdeen has been encountering real people. He encountered real people praying in the cold and he thought they would be better off praying inside his church in the warm.


The result has been warm congratulations from thinking, feeling people, and a storm of abuse from those who prefer the pleasures of prejudice. Because those he encountered praying were not Christian but belonged to one of the worlds other great monotheisms, Islam.


It appears that those attacking the Rev’d Poobalan are utterly ignorant of Islam. This is not the time nor yet the place, and I am not the person, to give you a full account of a noble religion, but let us deal with a few misconceptions. Allah is not a moon-god. He is the One True God that Christians love and try to follow. Islam does not believe that women should be oppressed and subjugated and denied an education, although regrettably a minority of its followers in unenlightened cultures do think that – and before we get sniffy about that we might stop and consider the really vile things a minority of Christians in our own country appear to believe. Not to mention the fact that our sister church in England still does not allow women to become bishops, and has just enthroned a man who still does not believe God blesses gay relationships despite what he admits is the evidence of his own eyes. But I digress.


Islam has as an utter key-stone the need to give to and support the poor, in a way that Christianity at its worse (though not at its best) simply ignores. Islam is to its core a generous faith. At times in history it was Islam which kept the light of learning alive, and the scholarship it promoted in science has left every one of us an important legacy. Indeed, the legacy of Islam in opening Western minds to the possibilities of creating clean, safe cities is also remarkable. Islamic states had them and we did not.


Never the less, a number of incredibly stupid people (have I offended them? Oh GOOD) have attacked Isaac through Facebook for his enlightened, sensible and utterly Christian stance. Our faith, too, is about generosity – about meeting people where they are and quietly, and for no ulterior motive, seeking to be of service to them. I just hope Isaac knows how many more people support him to the hilt.


4 responses to “Isaac Poobalan – real Christianity and real Islam

  1. Pingback: Congratulations to Isaac Poobalan and St John’s, Aberdeen

  2. This is such a heartwarming story, Rosemary, but somehow I missed it. Many thanks for alerting us to it. I do despair of some of my fellow Christians sometimes.

  3. Pingback: Christian Hospitality to Muslims – Aberdeen, Scotland | Kiwianglo's Blog

  4. Just came across this story, having followed a link from Kelvin Holdsworth’s blog to yours. Thank you so much for sharing it, and thank God for Isaac Poobalan! I work in a Catholic Sixth Form college- our asssembly this week consisted of a Catholic talking about his charity work with St Vincent de Paul, the reading of a list of names of recently deceased relatives of our students (followed by the “Eternal rest grant unto them…” prayer) and then finally two Muslim girls who spoke about Hussain, grandson of Muhammad (and his great stand against injustice); they then said a prayer. And it was wonderful! Christians and Muslims standing together, both affirming their core values and their trust in God, confidently and in harmony. I wish there was more of it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s